Crescent Beach

Restaurants in St. Augustine

Here are a few of our favorite dining spots in St. Augustine. If you’d like to see the individual restaurant’s website, just click on the links. Most have menus available.

95 Cordova at the Casa Monica Hotel
95 Cordova Street
Historic St. Augustine
904-810-6810
New World Electric Cuisine

A1A Aleworks
1 King St.
Historic St. Augustine
904-829-2977
New world cuisine & hand crafted beer

Beachcomber Restaurant
2 A Street
St. Augustine Beach
904-471-3744
Oceanfront deck – Very Casual w/Great food

Cafe Eleven
501 A1A Beach Blvd
St. Augustine Beach
904-460-9311

The Cellar Upstairs at San Sebastian Winery
157 King Street.
Historic St. Augustine
1-888-352-9463, 904-826-1594
Jazz hideaway – gourmet appetizers

Columbia Restaurant
98 St. George Street
Historic St. Augustine
904-824-3341
World famous Spanish cuisine

Fusion Point
237 San Marco Avenue
Historic St. Augustine
904-823-1444
Far East favorites, with sushi bar

Le Pavillon
45 San Marco Blvd.
Historic St. Augustine
904-824-6202
Extraordinary continental cuisine

Manatee Cafe
525 #106 State Road 16
St. Augustine
904-826-0210
Healthful Cuisine, several vegetarian selections

O.C. White’s
11 Avenida Menendez
Historic St. Augustine
904-824-0808
Fresh Seafood, choice steaks, chicken & pasta specialties

Old City House Restaurant
115 Cordova Street
Historic St. Augustine
904-826-0184
World Cuisine served in a romantic & friendly setting

Raintree Restaurant
102 San Marco Avenue
Historic St. Augustine
904-824-7211
Continental selection, colonial setting

Salt Water Cowboys
229 Dondanville Road
St. Augustine Beach South
904-471-2332

Scarlett O’Hara’s
70 Hypolita St.
Historic St. Augustine
904-824-6535
Atmosphere & Ale

Sea Oats Caffe
1075 A1A Beach Blvd. (Publix Plaza)
St. Augustine Beach
904-471-7350

South Beach Grill
45 Cubbedge Road
Crescent Beach (right next to public beach access)
904-471-8700
Oceanfront deck & bar, fantastic food

Stir It Up
18 A St
St. Augustine Beach
(904) 461-4552
Positive Food in a Positive Place

Sunset Grille
421 A1A Beach Blvd.
St. Augustine Beach
904-471-5555

Tony’s Pizza
6975 A1a S # 2
Crescent Beach
904-471-9027

Zaharias Restaurant
3945 A1A S
St Augustine, FL 32080
(904) 471-4799
See our breakfast review here.

Dining Guides

While you’re at the First Choice Vacation Rentals office in St. Augustine, be sure to grab our local dining magazine The Restaurant Times, for full menus, coupons, and more. Restaurant Times is free, and available all over town. Aside from our office, you can find a wide variety of informative pamphlets at the St. Augustine Pier, and the St. Augustine Visitors Center.

Also be sure to join the local Facebook group NE Florida Restaurant Guide by Swip Alot. This online resource allows restaurants to update their menus daily, and offer daily specials and coupons. Join at Swip Alot NE Florida Restaurant Guide.

Rental Condos

Rental Homes

Pet Friendly Vacation Rentals

St. Augustine Realty

Local Resources

1-904-429-7373

First Choice Florida Local Dining St. Augustine

Anastasia Island Attractions

The downtown historic district can get pretty crowded, Take the opportunity to visit some Anastasia Island attractions.

Sure, there’s that long stretch of sand and water on our east side. And if you’re in one of our island rentals, it’s just a few yards away. Anastasia Island has miles of white sugar sand beaches and all natural dunes. These are the finest beaches the north Florida area has to offer.

South Anastasia

The south end of the island is known as Summer Haven, or Matanzas. There’s some great food out this way at Matanzas Innlet Restaurant. Throw in your line with some fishing off the bridge. Take in the nature trails at northeast waterway park.

The primary attractions at this end of the island though is Fort Matanzas. Similar to the Castillo de San Marcos in the historic district, Fort Matanzas was integral in protecting St. Augustine in our early years. You get to the fort on a free boat ride via the National Park Service. Fort Matanzas is rather small, and your entire tour will be less than an hour, including boat ride. There’s also a movie about the fort inside the gift shop.

Central Anastasia

Stop in Crescent Beach for an incredible lunch from either Tonys Pizza, or South Beach Grill. Visit the Surf Station II to get some gear, then hit the waves in this gorgeous stretch of sugar sand beach. There are plenty more fishing opportunities near here. Head under the SR 206 Bridge, or over to Frank Butler Park West.

The Butler Beach area is rapidly expanding, now with shopping plazas and restaurants. Dollar General has you covered with light groceries, and you can grab a delicious lunch at Redfrog and McToads.

North Anastasia

Continuing north we begin coming into the St. Augustine Beach area. Do not miss dinner at Salt Water Cowboys. Grab your swimming gear at Alvins Island, or Nautilus At the Beach. Groceries and other supplies set us at the midway of the island. Winn Dixie has a grocery and a liquor store on the west side of A1A, right at Beach Blvd. There’s also a Publix grocery and Dollar Tree sitting in the other larger plaza across the street. You’ll find ice cream, Starbucks, Subway, and many more stores to make your vacation a success.

Anastasia Island

Local Dining